"(Kirsten) Scott and Mahany have pipes to shake the heavens, and they absolutely soar on 'High Enough'."
"Drew (C.J. Eldred, though played with gnarly aplomb by understudy Michael Mahany on the night I attended) is a city boy, born and raised in South Detroit."
"[In First Date] the acting is first-rate. Michael Mahany is Aaron, and he's the epitome of awkward, needy insecurity. But he's not locked into this attitude: with Casey's help (and a technique right out of Gestalt therapy) he eventually finds his inner Rhett Butler and confronts the reality of his too-often-fantasized ex"
Creative Loafing
Tampa, Fl

"As 'the voice of East High School' (Michael Mahany in Ira Glass mode) sends out official announcements, and real communication is made via ever-present cell phones, the student body observes the unusual shifts in loyalties."
Chicago Sun-Times

"...secondary characters (Olivia Oguma as student composer Kelsi Neilson and Michael Mahany as Jack Scott, "the voice of East High School") really add the glue that holds the show together with style."
Cape Cod Times